First Look Fair: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya S2


The Singularity is here. I see the blogosphere being sucked into a spinning vortex from this point forward…and I am willingly one of the first!

Three shows were responsible for getting me back into anime in the summer of 2006: Honey and Clover, Monster,…and The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. As of today, Haruhi has restarted again, and it couldn’t have reintroduced itself in a more familiar way.

It was Ray, the co-founder of this site, who introduced me to Haruhi. He was telling me about this crazy show that had a bizarre first episode, and at the time I was busy rediscovering anime and I had plenty on my plate. I didn’t start watching the show until episode 6 or 7 had already come out, but immediately, from the brilliant meta-humor of the “student film” onwards, I was enthralled by the show’s mix of sly otaku satire and science fiction philosophizing. Never mind that a host of postmodern imitators have come along since, or that meta-humor is now an overused trope in anime; it’s nice to finally see Kadokawa finally stop trolling the fans and actually releasing something for a change.


This episode is more in the spirit of the quieter, sci-fi oriented episodes of the series, such as the latter installments of the “main storyline” in season 1. Once again, Haruhi is strangely melancholy; once again, time travel paradoxes are involved and Yuki goes into full technobabble mode. Of course there’s some moe moe service for all the Mikuru fans (though I guess there was no kiss after all! Kyon, you wuss!), but it actually appears to be a plot-heavy episode of sorts, in which we find out even more about the strangeness of Yuki and that Haruhi’s life may be much more preplanned than we originally thought. We get that familiar tinge of poignancy in her Nazca-like drawings on the field, which is simply a message calling out to the world to acknowledge her, to give her significance–something we know she longs for as was revealed at the end of the main story last time around. From that perspective, her sadness at realizing that wishes take so long to reach the stars is understandable. I remember always wondering why such a terrific comedy was called the melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, but eventually it became clear why that was so, and this episode continues in that tradition.


The schedule I found here appears to indicate that they intend to show the episodes in pure chronological order from the light novels; in fact, the bulk of the new episodes will be shown in the late summer and early fall. So we’re actually going to have to wait a while for an arc to show up for real; the next new ep is being shown on June 18th and will continue for a few weeks, with another arc coming in August. Will this dampen fan enthusiasm? I don’t know. In either case we won’t be getting that time switcheroo which made the original airing so special, but hopefully, the stories will hold up anyway and the spirit that captivated so many fans three years ago will continue into this new season. So far, it’s off to a good start.

Welcome back, Haruhi and company.

Author: gendomike

Michael lives in the Los Angeles area, and has been into anime since he saw Neon Genesis Evangelion in 1999. Some of his favorite shows include Full Metal Alchemist, Honey and Clover, and Welcome to the NHK!. Since 2003 he has gone to at least one anime convention every year. A public radio junkie, which naturally led to podcasting, he now holds a seminary degree and is looking to become Dr. Rev. Otaku Bible Man any day now. Michael can be reached at You can also find his Twitter account at @gendomike.

5 thoughts on “First Look Fair: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya S2

  1. I think them airing season 1 and 2 weaved together is their new — gimmick sounds too harsh — style of episode ordering.  I wonder where that linked blog got that list from?  Made up?

  2. I don’t know…
    It feels like the magic kinda died after the 2 years of getting rickrolled over and over… maybe reading the baka-tsuki translations made it less unpredictable.
    I hope I forgot all the other stuff I read for the light novel… T_T
    Still I enjoyed the episode.

  3. Found myself watching the new show with what started out as a slight line on my face, a smile about halfway through and by the end it turned into an ivory graveyard. I couldn’t help but forgive Kadokawa for all of their red herrings simply because one of my favorite anime casts was back. 

    I also agree with Mike that it felt like a story from the latter half of the first season (this episode lets me stop calling it a singular series) with some great sci-fi terminology from Nagato. As always Kyon is the most put upon person on the planet. 

    With this declaration by the producers, I hope we can now look forward to more, if erratically released, Haruhi.

  4. Michael: to tell you the truth, I’ve got no way of confirming anything. It’s plausible, if they continue airing it in chronological order as they have done already. In either case it stretches the hype across two whole seasons. I suppose KyoAni fanboys still have K-ON! to salivate over for the remainder of the spring…

    korosora: welcome back, first off! I’ve only read the first light novel, of which the anime was really a faithful adaptation, so I don’t have any advance knowledge of anything. I tend to watch the anime first in general; only now, for instance, have a I started reading the Toradora! light novels and have been enthralled by the story all over again.

    Eeeper: erratic is how Haruhi-sama works, you know. It’s a reflection of her maze mind. As for Kadokawa, I suspect in the long run they will be thought of as marketing geniuses–or the fanboys remembered as supreme chumps.

  5. Hmm. The “new” show looks lower budget to me, with as much fruitiness as before. Sure, it’s interesting, but it’s also forced. Maybe it’s the extreme politeness in the tea-serving session, or Mikuru’s sudden burst into tears. 

    At least characters like Haruhi and Nagato have been consistently awesome. Kyon’s still got it as well. I was hoping for more of a deviation in how the show was done, though.

    Ah well. I’ll still be looking out for it. It was interesting.

Comments are closed.