Review: Myself; Yourself–An Beautiful, Incomplete Melody

And so I get to review it.
And so I get to review it.

It’s been a long time since I’ve watched a show that has given me so many conflicted feelings. There were aspects of this series that were very good, verging on excellent; and then there were aspects that bordered on the incompetent. The final episodes are a microcosm of all these issues put together, in this fascinating, flawed take on the romance genre.

The reason revealed, at last. (Like we didn’t know.)
The reason revealed, at last. (Like we didn’t know.)

I still stand by my contention that the Hinako episodes, the Higurashi grandma, and possibly the incest subplot involving the twins, could be dropped to create a much stronger story. This series would have made an excellent six episode OVA. Because when you consider the Sana/Nanaka storyline by itself, the following things come to light:

  • So many plot elements come full circle effectively: Sana and Nanaka’s suicide attempts. The meaning of the title “Myself; Yourself.” The search both Sana and Nanaka had for each other in their time apart.
  • Unlike with Asami’s revelations, we were very well prepared, perhaps TOO prepared, for Sana’s big revelation at the end of episode 12. Actually, I take that back. It added to both the pathos and shock of seeing Nanaka attempting the same thing, since we more or less know that Sana cut his wrists at one point.
  • Oddly enough, the discovery of Nanaka’s origins seemed less shocking than with Asami’s revelations too, and a bigger emotional gut punch. I suspected the uncle was a red herring all along, and I wondered why he and his wife had a different hair color from Nanaka to begin with. Once again, we were somewhat more prepared for the big moment, though I felt a small bit of “soap opera melodrama” when it came.

I almost got the feeling that the writers began with Sana/Nanaka alone, finished that story, and discovered they needed to fill time. That’s definitely how the other plots felt, stuck on. When the core story is as strong as it is, and the others so much weaker, that’s my only conclusion or rationale.

‘Nuff said.
‘Nuff said.

And it is strong indeed. I had bated breath as Sana was trying to find out where Nanaka had disappeared to, even though I knew the most likely answer. I felt horror as she watched her father declare that he would have aborted her if he had known the truth, and real pathos as Sana quietly told her that he had come back for the same reason that she had put the letters in the mailbox. (The mailbox is still a wonderful connecting motif.) The reason why he was suicidal was explained just a tad too quickly, though–and I should have taken it as a warning for what was to come. But at the moment the scene was ending, I was saying to myself: “dude, I think they pulled it off. There were parallels and emotional resolution. This is a GOOD ending!” I had the tremor in my heart that comes when I watch something emotionally fulfilling.

That’s all the Shuri you fanboys are gonna get!
That’s all the Shuri you fanboys are gonna get!

But the epilogue of episode 13 undid so much of it, mostly through poor pacing and haste. It’s a shame, because I think they only needed maybe 5 extra minutes to bring a natural end to the entire series, but lacking that, they had to resort to cameos “ten years later.” Here’s Hinako with a much younger boy; here’s Aoi showing that the park had been saved by Asami no less; here’s a fleeting shot of Shuri holding hands with someone we can’t even see; and–most grievously for an ostensible romance–here’s a proposal scene that cuts cut off before the big moment! Instead they cut to Sana and the sensei afterwards, nonchalantly talking about how he was able to give her the diamond ring. It was as if the network were literally whipping the writer and saying “hurry along, now.” When Nanaka played her childhood composition, it had a chance to salvage something, but again the scene ended unnaturally, with just her announcing the title as the last word before credits. They didn’t bow to the usual convention of showing us the faces of all the main characters as they hear the piece. They just…stopped. It felt like it was almost over, but not quite. Then we see the fan service ending of Shuri begins.

It wouldn’t be such a huge letdown if the core elements of the story weren’t so darned good. I’m a sucker for circular endings. I love how they brought the real meaning of the title into the end. I love the central story of two lost young people with similar weaknesses being able to be there for each another; they helped restore each other to wholeness. But the epilogue is part and parcel of a whole series of storytelling sins: awkward pacing, inserting subplots in strange places and failing to resolve them (twins? Hinako?), and largely useless side characters as a result.

You know, it wouldn’t be surprising if it turned out that this was this director or writer’s first major outing. It has a lot of the problems one associates with ambitious first timers: many good ideas, and many good individual scenes (the Asami confession scene, by itself, is actually quite good, as is the goodbye scene with the twins). But it also bit off more than it could chew and has yet to acquire the effortless pacing that an experienced storyteller can summon.

What do you call a romance story that skips the proposal scene? Inept
What do you call a romance story that skips the proposal scene? Inept

This is such a mixed bag. There were great moments jumbled with not-so-great moments, and the result is a mess which almost righted itself by the end. It can’t be judged like other harem or romance series; it was definitely trying to head somewhere different, somewhere better even. I always try to honor genuine ambition and convention breaking whenever I see it, and there’s a lot of it here; just before the epilogue I was almost ready to agree with Owen about it being the ultimate “post-harem” show. At its best, it had good drama and a semblance of real emotion, which means that for this staff and writing team, there is hope: they are not necessarily destined for mediocrity, if they learn from their mistakes.

Perhaps somebody should do what some Star Wars fans did after the release of The Phantom Menace and produce a “Phantom Edit” version of Myself; Yourself, with only the Sana/Nanaka parts included and any necessary extra scenes that help it along. I would be very interested to see whether my theory that this would make it a lot stronger is true. The “Phantom Edit” may or may not have influenced George Lucas to decrease Jar Jar Binks’ roles in the future movies, and while it’s too late for this particular franchise to be fixed, maybe, just maybe, someone could show them they had a real diamond in the rough here. Or, like the title song–a beautiful, soaring melody, cut off before its time was up.

Anime Diet Daily Recommended Allowances

  • Animation: 70%. Passable; rather generic character designs. Nothing in this show called for very showy visuals. Why is the rock concert in the OP better animated than most of the show, though? The ED scenes also became woefully inappropriate later on.
  • Sound/Music: 68%. Mostly forgettable. Sometimes the cheery preview music really stuck out like a sore thumb. I didn’t particularly like either the OP or ED song.
  • Voice Acting: 85%. A lot of the voice actors for the central characters, as well as Asami, really came through in the big scenes with real emotional nuance and passion. They came through even when those scenes weren’t fully earned by the plot. Points off, though, for casting Aoi with Chiyo-chan’s seiyuu. She sounds like that apparently even ten years later in the story.
  • Story: 65%/88%. The second score is for the Sana/Nanaka storyline until the very end, which, while melodramatic, had the most emotional impact and felt the least illogical–it even had some good literary touches. The first score is for everything else and the epilogue, which even when there were individually good scenes was riddled with implausibilities and groan-worthy moments, and poor direction to boot.
  • Overall: 70%. It tried so, so hard to be different, to be interesting. At times it actually succeeded. Those moments are worthwhile and make the show worth watching, but only if you can stomach everything else, which not everyone can. I respect the creators of this show, though. May they go on to better things with their obvious and considerable talents.

8 thoughts on “Review: Myself; Yourself–An Beautiful, Incomplete Melody”

  1. I think you nailed it. Myself;Yourself is that one show you really, really want to love, except there are some things about it that are incredibly frustrating.

    (So, uh, Aoi = Myself;Yourself, then. XD)

    I think Grandma Kaji was a pretty necessary part to the show, to act as a pseudo-red herring (plot-wise) and as the transition between ‘silly show’ and ‘serious show’, personally. I don’t think the sideplots are much weaker than the main one (Nanaka/Sana). They’re a little less believable and a little less resolved, but they were every bit as interesting; kind of like two contrasts, now that I think of it. Sana/Nanaka was predictable yet powerful, and the rest were stunning and shocking (and kind of stupid ridiculous at points).

    I liked the ’10 years later’ part if only because of the full-circle-ness of it all, but I do agree they needed more time. They cut out the proposal! You just don’t do that.

    (Also, they ended with a pan up.)

    That said, I’m pleased with the series as a whole as they managed to pull Sana/Nanaka’s plots to an enjoyable and fulfilling closure, and kind of quick-tied up the rest of the characters instead of leaving them out of the story. It just seems funny that a romance story like this featured something on the line of zero confessions and zero kiss scenes between main characters (I think Hinako got the farthest!?). Maybe that’s a sign of how ‘different’ it’s trying to be.

  2. When Aoi’s voice was still the same after 10 years, I had a sudden thought: How does her seiyuu sound like? If her seiyuu, too, speaks with that voice…

    But yeah, I’m with you on the opinions. It had a good end, but the Hinako subplot, for example, never really ended; or rather, it’s hard to see where it began.

    Also, the person Shuri is holding hands with is Shuu. You can tell by the matching wristbands. Or perhaps you already mentioned that, and I missed it; but I just thought to point it out anyway.

  3. @CCY: I’ve been thinking about it, and I’m beginning to wonder whether it’s even fair to call M;Y a real romance; the emotional climax was reached, after all, not with a kiss or love confession but with a suicide confession. It’s more about self-realization and discovery in that case. I still think though that the other subplots were a lot less believable and more annoying as a result. Had each one gotten its own mini-series to flesh them out, I might think differently.

    @Sylon Beta: Ah. I did notice the wristband, actually, but I wasn’t 100% sure. They’re being sneaky about it, though, because I think they are a little nervous about the incestuous implications. They would have done better if they had not even brought up incest to begin with (more believable) or, if they had to, did it much more upfront and unashamed, since the twins were supposed to be sympathetic characters.

  4. i absolutely agree with you.. M;Y is an anime that i WANT to love,but then there is a question inside me that goes,’should i?’..the sana/nanaka story wasn’t as much interesting as i thought it should be.there weren’t even heart whelming or tickling moments except for the short part where they were about to hold hands but hinako found them.The sana/hinako part was even more interesting than theirs..The ‘sana suicide attempt’ that i thought was supposed to be one of the main things that the story would revolve in was explained like explaining to your mom why you overcooked the rice..
    sure thing i understand the brotherly and sisterly love between shuu and shuri but it seems that everyone is not like me which is true for a lot of some, questioned about incestuous implications. though im sure it could have had a much greater continuation or(i dont know how to explain it).
    The ending was not satisfying(though this statement can’t really explain the way you will feel after seeing the last episode..
    well,i think what i just want to say is that,this anime is one of those that after seeing the whole thing would make you say like ‘THAT’S IT??’ but would make you continue saying ‘I WANT MORE’

  5. I’m surprised you didnt pay attention when Shuri and her brother were shopping shuri picked out a orange bracelet and Shusuke offered to pay for it. And went they left shuri had orange and Shusuke had blue. It showed shuri at the end holding hand with some one it was Shusuke because she had the orange bracelet on and he had his blue one one

Leave a Reply