Comments on: Review: The Sacred Blacksmith ep 07 – Questions

By: Orion

Orion — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 09:29:35 +0000

I dunno. She starts out a fairly typical 1st level fighter and progresses nicely. Episode 8 of the anime’ is really where she comes into her own.
Why are there Demon Swords? They tell you quite plainly their purpose is to “slay God”. Once we find out why there’s a freaking big volcano next to the town (and who builds a town next to a live volcano if they don’t have to?) and what this “God” they’re supposed to kill is, we’ll answer the rest of the questions.

By: rayyhum777

rayyhum777 — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 13:42:02 +0000

@ Silver – that seems to be a plot hole that has not been explained at all.

By: Silver

Silver — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 07:50:24 +0000

@ rayyhum777

Ah I see. I understand what you meant now. It is frustrating in that aspect. If you read some of the comments from the other blogs, some people thought it was some kind fan service due to how many times she kept on losing. Hopefully it turns differently later on in the novel but that seems like a long way off for the anime unless they change it all around which can be a good thing but can also be very bad.

One thing I was wondering if you can answer this but is there any reason why Aria can’t transfer to being a human when Cecily loses? I mean, those girls were walking off with Aria and she could just turn back to her human form right?

By: rayyhum777

rayyhum777 — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 07:42:20 +0000

All the characters are quite likable and that can be a type of weakness because there isn’t anyone that can draw very strong emotions from the audience, except the villain. I recommend staying on the show anyway as the novel does show moments of emotional intensity. I think the real draw here is the growth in mind and power of Cecily, but she remains the damsel in distress so far, even in the novel.

By: rayyhum777

rayyhum777 — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 07:39:46 +0000

@ schneider – Fio doesn’t get to do too much. As a matter of fact, in the anime, some of the dialogue that Fio has in the novel is transferred to the mother, who mostly lay in bed without saying much in the novel.
Charolette is a much more complex character with her motive. There will be political intrigue involved. But the intrigue will probably not satisfy the thirst of a fan of European style politics.

By: rayyhum777

rayyhum777 — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 07:37:21 +0000

@ Silver – Let me revise my comment – I’m rather frustrated that Cecily always turn into the damsel in distress – despite being a fighting damsel. She never wins any battle and it’s always up tp Luke to save her (hey what are male characters for, right). Having used to seeing powerful women that can handle themselves in a fight, this moe-featured Cecily does not please me. After all, she was the character that started the show and I simply got sick of seeing her lose. I do like how she keeps on looking for new ways to get better.

By: Silver

Silver — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 03:35:13 +0000

@ schneider

Yeah, that maid is pretty darn awesome.

Anyway, I say that both Cecily and Charlotte are really good people. It’s also nice how Fio is there show that the people in the the Campbell’s household are pretty much family to one another. They are treat each other as equal hence that’s why Fio was like that to Cecily. Also, you can pretty much see everyone has high trust in one another. It’s great to see Cecily and the people in the household very humble.

After this episode, I could say the same exact thing about Charlotte. She only acts high and mighty as a way to protect herself but deep inside, she’s also a very humble person.

Overall, both Cecily and Charlotte in my eyes are pretty wonderful in that aspect. Anyway, Aria was pretty awesome but wow, she sure has an appetite!

By: schneider

schneider — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 03:21:24 +0000

Surprisingly I like this episode a lot, and wish there were more of them (instead of a dinky defeat evil cloaked people plot), but the final scene puts a damper on my hopes.

I’m amazed how a brat like Charlotte is a better and more interesting person than Cecily, at least to me.

PS: Does the maid do more stuff later on? I bet she could take anything the show/novel has to offer!

By: Silver

Silver — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 01:17:12 +0000

@ rayyhum777

Haha, wow, it seems like we might end up keep double posting or something.

Anyway, I agree with you about The Sacred Blacksmith. Some of the fantasy elements just don’t really click with me but somehow, they mesh together and provide something that’s just works and also entertaining enough that makes you want to continue watching it.

One thing I don’t agree though is that you think Cecily does not have the mental toughness. I think otherwise. Even after losing so many times, she never becomes depressed or white about it but continues to go forward. She may not be as strong as Lina Inverse but her mental strength is. The good thing is that Cecily is still continue to make herself strong so hopefully she will become something like Lina both in terms of strength and mental strength.

Also, you mention translated volumes? So it’s released in the US? Thanks.

By: Silver

Silver — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 01:11:10 +0000

@ rayyhum777

I would recommend it. One problem just to let you know that it tends to end on cliffhangers so it can be rather frustrating at times because it does a pretty good job of drawing you in. I would say watch up to the recent episodes first then think about whether you would want to review it or not. The series can be a hit and miss just like most series. Also, just in case, the plot is just not entirely about delivery mail but there are quite a bit more to it. You could also try reading the manga of it if you want.